Agata e Romeo was recently on everyone’s
lips as the must-go restaurant. Set somewhat apart from the bustle near the
Basilica di Santa Maria Maggiore, it has all the trappings of très haute
cuisine: the dollop-and-swirls approach to plating, formal service, and tastefully
small portions. Dishes range from inventive—grilled foie gras with red-onion
ice cream—to the high end of ordinary (grilled salmon). Dish to get: The risotto with seafood and lemongrass sauce
earned a place in Guida Gallo: 101 risotti dei migliori
ristoranti del mondo—“101 risottos from the best restaurants in the
world” (Via Carlo Alberto 45; 446-6115; entrées from $56; tasting menu with
wine pairings, $230).
Il Pagliaccio, near the Campo dei Fiori, is the sort of
establishment where your handbag gets a special stool and the menu of bottled
waters takes up an entire page. The patrons are as stylish as the decor. The
servings are piccolissimi by traditional Italian standards. Creative and
unexpected combinations—scallops with pear cream and cashews—are handled with
finesse. Dish to get: Exquisite desserts from chef Marion Lichtle
include a concoction built on chestnut ice cream (Via dei Banchi Vecchi 129;
6880-9595; entrées from $56).
Trattoria, Filippo La Mantia’s first restaurant in Rome, is
reached through a discreet sliding glass door that looks like the entrance to a
small bank branch. Two flights up, the austere modern dining room feels
light-years away from the antiquity of the Centro Storico.Dish to get: The divine caponata with pine nuts and a hint
of Asian spice is an inspired tweak of a Sicilian classic. The star chef still
keeps his spoon in the pan here, even though he has opened another venue—see
below (Via Pozzo delle Cornacchie 25; 6830-1427; entrées from $32).
Filippo La Mantia, the chef’s gorgeous new space in the
Majestic Hotel, quickly became the toast of Rome for foodies who don’t believe
innovative cuisine has to be served in a minimalist setting. Here, La Mantia
has continued his one-man campaign against garlic and onion (he won’t use them)
and demonstrated for discerning diners how citrus accents enhance food’s
natural flavors. Dish to get: The octopus salad with
lemon sauce and celery (4214-4715; entrées from $56).
Quinzi e Gabrieli, convenient to parliament and the
government ministries, is favored by power players in business attire. The
waiter begins pouring champagne the minute you arrive at the table, ready or
not, and a parade of elaborate seafood platters follows. Dish to get: The cuttlefish with crunchy artichokes is a
nice alternative to the many lobster dishes (Via delle Coppelle 5; 6879-389;
entrées from $50).
Glass Hostaria’s chef, Cristina Bowerman, spent
14 years in Austin before returning to Rome to earn a Michelin star. The room
features a modern glass design fitted into a medieval building, and the crowd
is equally modern and stylish. The menu is a list of surprising combinations,
such as lamb in a coffee crust. Dish to get: Pine nut
pasta buttons in pesto consommé (Vicolo del Cinque 58; 5833-5903; entrées from
$35).
PIZZA
La Montecarlo is one of the two pizzerie
near the Piazza Navona that dominate everyone’s list. And it is the only one
open at lunch. It’s bare-bones, with pies slapped onto dented aluminum
platters, but the thin-crust pizza is outstanding. Pie to
get: Squash blossoms with a white sauce (Vicolo Savelli 13; 686-1877;
pizzas from $15).
Baffetto, nearby, is mentioned in the same breath, but it’s
only open in the evening. Go early (before 7 p.m.) to avoid a wait. Pie to get: Mushroom, artichoke, and sausage with an egg on
top (Via del Governo Vecchio 114; 686-1617; pizzas from $12).
Casina Valadier is a stately villa at the edge of the Borghese
Gardens. A city built on hills has many good views, but this is one of Rome’s
most congenial. Both the villa’s wraparound balcony and its ground-floor
terrace offer a broad prospect out over the city. The Sunday lunch is
old-style: two hours of seriously indulgent eating. Dish to get: Whether it’s on the menu or not, the chef’s
signature beef fillet with foie gras—filetto di manzo al vino rosso con fegato
grasso e pommes fondants—is always available (Piazza Bucarest; 6992-2090;
entrées from $20).
La Terrazza, the restaurant and bar on the
roof of the Hotel Eden, is great for cocktails and spectacular panoramic views. Dish to get: Hazelnut-crusted lamb loin with wild mushroom
cream (Via Ludovisi 49; 478-891; entrées from $46).
NEIGHBORHOOD STARS
Rome’s neighborhoods have long had their own cultures and, in the past, even
proprietary cuisines. Although the city’s hoods have largely lost their insular
coherence, Romans still go to often-boisterous local restaurants to experience
the soul of their communities. Some favorites:
CENTRO STORICO
This is the political
and sightseeing heart of the city, which the restaurants clearly reflect:
They’re always crowded with a lively mix of local politicians, civil servants,
and urban bourgeoisie, along with visitors of every stripe. Expect menus heavy on
classic favorites and lots of power lunching.
Maccheroni, a short walk from the Pantheon, serves reliably
good Roman classics at a great price in mismatched rooms that look like the
inside of an old Roman apartment. It’s the sort of establishment where “Mama is
on vacation” suffices to explain what menu items aren’t available. Dish to get: A big, delicious bowl of tonnarelli, which is
an extra-large version of spaghetti (Piazza delle Coppelle 44; 6830-7895;
entrées from $14).
Armando al Pantheon may be smack in the middle
of the tourist stream, but it attracts a loyal clientele of locals who are
drawn to its small, wood-paneled dining room and good wine list. Dish to get: The fruit-filled torta antica roma is like a refined version of
strawberry cheesecake (Salita de’ Crescenzi 31; 6880-3034; entrées from $22).
Settimio all’Arancio is a nondescript place tucked
away in a residential area near the Fontanella Borghese. The crowd is largely
regulars in media and the arts. Dish to get: The
divinely succulent whole fish baked in salt (Via dell’Arancio 50; 687-6119;
entrées from $22).
Trattoria Al Moro, near the Pantheon, tries to be
all things to all people: a cozy insider’s spot for Rome’s movers and shakers,
and an all-purpose night out for visitors. The result is that it has an endless
menu. Bonus points for going with a Roman insider: If the waiters don’t know
your father or your position in government, they aren’t likely to help you
out. Dish to get: The seasonal specialties. Look for anything
made with ovoli, a rare egg-shaped mushroom (Vicolo delle Bollette 13;
678-3495; entrées from $22).
TRASTEVERE
On the western side of
the Tiber, Trastevere had its own mix of Jews, Romans, and Greeks, as well as
its own dialect and flavorful cuisine. Since gentrifying in the 1970s, the old
working-class area has become a chic historic neighborhood.
Enoteca Ferrara is, according to a Roman expat I know,
one of the few decent restaurants left in the area. Dimly lit, it was opened in
the late 1990s by a group of women who were trailblazers in modernizing the
standard wine emporium. Dish to get: Gnocchi malfatti
with sugo aglione, hand-shaped gnocchi with tomatoes, garlic, red pepper, and
parsley (Piazza Trilussa 41; 5833-3920; entrées from $24).
Le Mani in Pasta, a traditional neighborhood joint, has a
loyal citywide following. We enjoyed a great seafood platter, a memorable fresh
artichoke and Parmesan salad, and an epiphanic Gorgonzola ice cream. The place
is tiny, so book in advance and request a table upstairs or you’ll be shunted
to the smoking room in the basement. Dish to get: Tuna in a
pistachio crust (Via dei Genovesi 37; 581-6017; entrées from $35).
MONTI
Around three of the
Roman hills, the city’s oldest and largest neighborhood remains hyper-urban,
intensely multicultural, and increasingly interesting for its numerous shops
and galleries, nightlife, and superb ethnic restaurants.
La Taverna dei Fori Imperiali is the kind of homey
place where a local dispenses with the menu and takes the daily special, a
perfectly executed version of an Italian standard: filetto di manzo,
saltimbocca, spaghetti all’amatriciana. Dish to get: Whatever
the kitchen is recommending (Via della Madonna dei Monti 9; 679-8643; entrées
from $18).
Urbana 47, one of a new breed of Roman restaurants
committed to locavore values, has the names of its suppliers written right on
the seasonal menu. Dish to get: In winter, the savory
pumpkin ravioli. In early spring, fresh pecorino. The cocktail hour buffet is a
good way to sample the wares (Via Urbana 47; 4788-4006; entrées from $20).